Comparing Plastic Prototype Manufacturing Techniques: Which is Right for Your Project?

Todd Nesnick
Tech0 Comments 0

 

 

Rapid prototyping is an essential part of product development. It allows designers and engineers to test and refine their designs before investing in costly tooling for high-volume production. In recent years, there has been a significant shift towards rapid prototyping, which has enabled faster and more cost-effective production of prototypes. Among all the material types, plastic is a very common one in prototyping. Here, we will discuss the most popular plastic prototype manufacturing techniques and help you determine which one is best for your project.

There are several techniques available for manufacturing plastic prototypes, each with its own set of advantages and disadvantages. Throughout this article, we will compare and contrast three of the most popular methods, as well as an emerging technology called rapid tooling.

 

3D Printing

3D printing, also known as additive manufacturing, is a process of building a three-dimensional object by depositing layers of material on top of each other. The process starts with a digital 3D model, which is sliced into thin layers, and the printer uses the design data to print each layer.

Advantages of 3D Printing for Plastic Prototype Manufacturing:

  • Fast production of plastic prototypes
  • Affordable production of complex designs
  • Capable of producing intricate geometries and internal structures

Disadvantages of 3D Printing for Plastic Prototype Manufacturing:

  • Limited material choices
  • Limited surface finish options (ABS and Nylon are usually the top two choices.)
  • Slow for high-volume production

Examples of When 3D Printing Might Be the Best Choice for a Project:

  • Creating intricate or complex geometries
  • Producing small volumes of parts
  • When the speed of production is important

 

CNC Machining

CNC (Computer Numerical Control) machining is a subtractive manufacturing process that removes material from a block or sheet of material to create a part. A computer-controlled cutting tool is used to remove material from the raw stock, following a set of instructions provided by a computer-aided design (CAD) file. A CNC milling prototype is always the first choice for a one-off plastic prototype part.

Advantages of CNC Machining for Plastic Prototype Manufacturing:

  • High accuracy and precision
  • Wide range of material options (ABS, PC, and PMMA are commonly chosen ones.)
  • Excellent surface finishes

Disadvantages of CNC Machining for Plastic Prototype Manufacturing:

  • High cost for complex geometries
  • Limited internal structures
  • Long lead times for larger parts

Examples of When CNC Machining Might Be the Best Choice for a Project:

  • Creating larger, more durable parts
  • Producing high-quality surface finishes
  • When precision and accuracy are essential

 

Vacuum Casting

Vacuum casting is a process that uses a silicone mold to create a plastic or rubber prototype. The mold is created from a CNC-machined or 3D-printed part, and liquid polyurethane (PU) resin is poured into the silicone mold. A vacuum is then applied to remove any air bubbles, and the mold is cured in an oven to harden the resin.

Advantages of Vacuum Casting for Plastic Prototype Manufacturing:

  • Affordable for small production runs
  • High-quality surface finishes
  • Wide range of material options (the materials have similar properties to ABS, PC, PMMA, soft rubber, and more.)

Disadvantages of Vacuum Casting for Plastic Prototype Manufacturing:

  • Limited production volumes for one mold
  • Limited geometries and internal structures
  • Longer lead times for larger parts

Examples of When Vacuum Casting Might Be the Best Choice for a Project:

  • Producing small runs of parts for testing and validation
  • When a high-quality surface finish is essential
  • When a wide range of materials is required

 

Rapid Tooling

Rapid tooling is an emerging technology that allows for the quick production of molds. The process involves making the steel, aluminum, resin, silicone, or ABS mold very fastly, which can then be used to produce plastic prototypes using injection molding. The advantage of rapid tooling is that it allows for the quick and cost-effective production of high-quality plastic parts as conventionally molded ones.

Advantages of Rapid Tooling for Plastic Prototype Manufacturing:

  • High-quality surface finishes
  • Wide range of material options (any plastics and rubber material of actual production grades)
  • Quick production of high volumes of parts

Disadvantages of Rapid Tooling for Plastic Prototype Manufacturing:

  • Higher upfront costs for mold creation
  • Limited geometry flexibility
  • Longer lead times for mold creation

Examples of When Rapid Tooling Might Be the Best Choice for a Project:

  • Producing high volumes of parts
  • When a high-quality surface finish is essential
  • When a wide range of materials is required

 

Conclusion

In conclusion, several plastic prototyping techniques are available, each with its benefits and drawbacks. When deciding which method to use, it is essential to consider the specific requirements of your project, such as the desired material, geometry, production volume, and lead time. By carefully evaluating your needs and weighing the pros and cons of each method, you can select the best technique to meet your project goals.